Trump’s Executive Orders vs. Biden’s Policies: The Fate of J.H. Campbell Coal Plant
President Trump’s recent executive orders aim to keep coal plants open by countering Biden’s environmental regulations, claiming these policies are forcing coal plants to shut down. However, the J.H. Campbell Coal Plant in Michigan is set to close in June 2025 as planned by Consumers Energy, despite political pressure.
President Trump recently signed a series of executive orders aimed at reviving the coal industry, claiming that these measures were necessary to counteract the “unscientific and unrealistic policies” enacted by the Biden administration. But is there any truth to Trump’s assertion that Biden’s policies are forcing coal plants to shut down? Let’s dig into the specifics.
The J.H. Campbell Coal Plant in West Olive/Port Sheldon, Michigan, is set to close in June 2025. Consumers Energy, the utility company operating the plant, has announced that the plant will officially retire and go “cold and dark” by that date. The plant will be demolished, and the site will be restored over time. This closure is part of Consumers Energy’s broader strategy to transition to cleaner energy sources. Consumers Energy
Despite the political pressure and recent executive orders, Consumers Energy has reiterated its commitment to close the Campbell plant as planned. The utility company filed a proposal with the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) in 2021, outlining its plan to close the plant by 2025. FOX 17 West Michigan News
President Trump’s executive orders, signed on April 8, 2025, aim to provide relief from stringent Biden-era environmental regulations, granting coal-fired power plants an extra two years to meet the EPA’s Mercury and Air Toxics Standards. The orders also include a moratorium on policies that Trump claims are discriminating against coal production. The White House, The Guardian
The executive orders accuse the Biden administration of implementing “unscientific and unrealistic policies” that are forcing coal plants to shut down. However, these claims are misleading, as Biden’s policies focus on stricter environmental regulations rather than direct shutdowns. The exact language used in the orders emphasizes the need to counteract these regulations to keep coal plants operational. AP News
Biden’s administration has introduced policies requiring coal plants to install carbon-capture technology and reduce pollutants discharged through wastewater. These regulations aim to mitigate the environmental impact of coal plants rather than force their closure. The Hill, EPA
While Trump’s executive orders claim that Biden’s policies are forcing coal plants to shut down, the reality is that Biden’s policies focus on stricter environmental regulations. Consumers Energy remains committed to closing the J.H. Campbell Coal Plant by June 2025, despite the political pressure to keep it open. The ongoing debate between economic interests and environmental protection continues to shape the future of coal and clean energy.
Sources:
